This is a little story about my last photo shoot. I hope you enjoy it. Let me know what you think with comments and ratings, please…Too long and boring? Interesting? Engaging? Let me know.
Lake Michigan Photo Shoot
I decided to get up early in the morning and go down to Lake Michigan to see what the shore line looks like. I am picturing blocks of ice jostling near the shore, perhaps making nice shapes for pictures. Small blocks of ice, perhaps a foot or two across. I set my cell phone to wake me at 6:30. It’s a luxury of the winter that the sun doesn’t get up very early. The forecast is for very cold temperatures; perhaps ten degrees. The wind is up a bit too, so it might be pretty bitter. I lay out all the long underwear and fleece layers I have so that I won’t be too cold when I’m down there. Standing around taking pictures is not very active work and you need to make allowances. I don’t want to be cold or I’ll never be able to focus on the pictures. It’s still pretty early, but I was up early this morning so I fall asleep pretty easily.
I awaken to the light of my cell phone as it turns on. It starts beeping and I fumble to turn it off. I’m feeling pretty groggy and my commitment to go down and take pictures wavers for a moment, but I decide to get showered and dressed and get moving. After showering, I put on the long underwear and fleece shirt I’ve laid out. On top of that goes a medium weight fleece jacket and my jeans. The jeans aren’t ideal, but they’re all I have with me. On top of the fleece jacket I add a down jacket. I know from experience that the down will keep me from even thinking about the cold. I have only a pair of low hiking boots to wear. I should have brought my high boots, but we have less snow at home than they do here in Grand Haven. I didn’t realize I would need them. I put on my wool hat with ear flaps that was given to me by my in-laws from Kurghistan. It’s not heavy, but it’s remarkably warm and the ear flaps are great for the ears. I’m wearing a pair of thick fleece gloves that combine a mitten with fingerless glove. I With the mitten folded down over the fingers, the gloves are quite warm, but you can pull the end of the mitten back to reveal bare fingers when you need them.
Fully girded for my little expedition, I head out to the car. When I step outside, it’s not as cold as I expect. When you live in Michigan, you gain a highly developed sense of outdoor temperature. I can almost immediately sense the temperature to within five or ten degrees. Does the air bite the skin when it hits you? Do the hairs in your nose freeze when you breathe in? It doesn’t feel like that kind of biting cold to me, so I’m pleased. On top of that, there’s no wind, so it’s not bad at all outside.
I hop in my truck and head to Panera for coffee and a bagel. Okay, so I’m a latte drinking expeditioner. I don’t care how early I have to get up to do something, I want to have a cup of coffee and a something in my stomach before I go out. Other people might roll out of bed, stumble into their clothes and head out the door in five minutes. Not me. I want my shower and coffee and bagel. I don’t care if I have to get up an hour earlier. It’s worth it to me to be clear headed when I start shooting.
When I was up at Pictured Rocks this past fall, I had a couple of experiences that highlighted why I prefer this. On my first morning there, I woke up hours before dawn, fully awake. I got up early, had a hot breakfast and went down to the beach to shoot the moon in the dark. It was probably an hour and a half before sunrise. I wound up having a relaxed time and getting wonderful pictures as the day slowly lightened in the East. The next day, I must have been tired, and I awoke with a start at near sunrise. I dressed hurriedly and stumbled down to the beach to try to catch the sunrise. I felt awful, and almost none of the pictures I took that morning were any good at all. It was the same beach, similar sunrise, and nothing was worth a thing. Creativity is a delicate thing, and it doesn’t happen for me with a muddled head, when you’re half asleep and in a hurry.
I have my bagel and coffee at Panera and head down to the beach. The parking lot is barely passable, with about a foot of snow in the entrance. It’s not bad once you get into the lot itself, but the snow plows have nearly blocked the entrance. This beach gets a lot of lake effect snow, as does all of Grand Haven, and the wind blows unobstructed all the way from Wisconsin, so there’s a lot of drifted snow around.
I get out the camera, mount it on the tripod, sling on the backpack with the other lenses and filters and stuff and head for the beach. It’s still almost dark. There’s a hint of light from behind me where the sun is thinking about rising in a while, but it’s still early enough that I don’t need to hurry. The lights are still on on the pier. It’s always a striking sight, the string of brilliant white lights with the red light on the lighthouse on the end. It’s beautiful, but I’m not here to shoot the pier, I’m interested in the ice and the water.

Even from the parking lot, I can see that the beach is not what I expected. There are big mounds of what appear to be snow covered sand well out into the water. My first thought is that these are piles of sand that the city has dumped along the water line in their perennial battle to keep the sand from drifting across the road along the lake. Now that I’m closer, I can see that in fact, these are big blocks of ice. I start heading for the beach. There are snow fences lining the parking lot to keep the aforementioned sand at bay, so I walk around the end of the fence to get to the beach. The snow has drifted pretty heavily along here, and I am immediately post-holing in to the deep snow. I’m wishing I had brought my tall boots, but I figure I’ll be alright because I won’t be out too long and I can always head for the car if I get too wet or cold. I can feel the snow getting in around my ankles, but I’m wearing good wool socks, so it’s not too bad.
I make my way down to the beach. The snow thins out after a while and there’s bare sand down along what I know to be the edge of the beach. I stop for a moment to take a quick shot of the lights of the pier. It’s not what I’m after, but it’s pretty cool looking and I might as well record it. At the the edge of where the water normally begins, instead of the water gently jostling little blocks of ice, there are perhaps 75 feet of jumbled ice out into the lake. The far outer edge of the ice has big blocks of ice with a lot of sand stuck in the frozen ice from the action of the waves. It’s not a smooth outer edge to the ice, but rather a series of promontories with deep cuts in between. The cuts are as much as 30 feet back from the face of the farthest points. This looks pretty interesting visually, so I’m eager to work my way out there.
The ice at the edge of the beach looks absolutely solid. It’s not smooth ice, but more like a frozen slush with a mixture of frozen snow and little chunks of ice. It looks as if it must be frozen right down to the sand, with no sense that there’s any water underneath it. It’s not moving and looks completely solid. I test the idea a bit gingerly, but it feels rock solid. It’s pretty slick, but since it’s not smooth, I can walk on it with a little care, without crampons. But crampons would be completely appropriate here. After crossing this frozen slurpee of ice and snow, I step up onto what appear to be thicker blocks of ice. They also seem to be frozen right down to the lake bed and seem completely solid. I clamber over higher and lower blocks of ice, working my way out to the crenelated edge of the ice where those deep cuts are making very interesting shapes where they reveal the water in between walls of ice.
I make my way out to the root of one of the deep cuts and can see the waves coming in being funneled down these narrowing fjords and splashing against the ice at the end of the cut, sometimes spraying water out onto the surrounding ice. I set up the tripod and start framing the first shot. The irregular funnel shaped openings look really cool set off against the white of the ice and snow. There are nice irregular clouds all the way out to the horizon that look great also. I zoom in and out and frame the first shot and take the first exposure. It’s still nearly dark, so it’s a thirty second exposure just to get a fairly dark image. I’m surprised that the camera is able to focus in this little light, but it does.

Here, I’m standing right at the edge of the ice. The wide angle lens makes it look as if I’m farther back from the edge than I am.
I begin moving around to frame more shots. I want to get as close as I can to the end of the little fjord that I’m shooting. The snow and ice in the foreground and not helping my composition, so I need to get closer. I have to be a careful here, because water is splashing out of the end of these inlets as the waves get funneled into the narrow end near where I am standing. The waves are making a vaguely disquieting sort of a galumphing sound as they slosh around and splash up under the ice I’m standing on. The ice along these fjords is undercut from the action of the warmer water, and there are visible cracks several feet back from the edges of the fjords where the ice is clearly in danger of collapsing into the water. I gingerly creep up as near the edge of the ice as I dare. I set up and take another couple of exposures, experimenting with composition to get the right proportions of sky and ice. I find that the widest angle I can shoot is the best and I wish I had a wider lens even than the 17-40mm zoom I’m using. Still, the images look very promising in the viewfinder with the dramatic sky hanging over the water and the dark water cutting these interestingly shaped notches into the ice in the foreground.
I take several exposure, moving the tripod around a bit to get as close to the edge as possible. I’d like to be right at the pointed end of this particular inlet, but water keeps splashing out of the end of the fjord as the waves come in. I don’t want to get soaked, so I stay just off to one side. All of a sudden, a particularly large wave runs in down the inlet I’m shooting, slamming up into the undercut end of the inlet. I’m in the middle of another long exposure, but I’m shocked to see the wave punch a foot and a half diameter hole through the ice not three feet from where I’m standing. A big chunk of ice is thrown out of the hold and dropped on the ice next to the new opening. I hadn’t realized just how undercut the ends of these inlets really are. I carefully take my tripod and move back a few feet from the edge of the ice. At the moment, I don’t really processed just how incredibly dangerous this is. It will come to me later, as I’m looking at the pictures and it comes back to me again later that night as I am trying to fall asleep.

The hole and block of ice at front popped out while I was standing immediately to the right of the hole, near the end of the fjord. See the previous photo to appreciate my position.
Had I been standing maybe two feet to my left when that wave came in, I would have been dropped down through that hole into the icy water. The water is probably more than chest deep, possibly over my head. If it’s over my head, I’m done for. There is no possible way I could have climbed up out of the overhanging ice walls, which are perhaps four to six feet above the surface of the water. If I were even able to tread water with my heavy boots and saturated clothing, it wouldn’t have been for long. The constant wave action, even though it’s fairly calm out, would have dunked me repeatedly in the ice water. Waves were building up to three or four feet as they reached the narrow end of these inlets, which is where I would have been. Even if I had been able to stand on the bottom, it’s very doubtful that I could have found any purchase on the face of the ice without an ice axe and crampons. Note to self. Buy ice axe and crampons.
Even with an ice axe, no two ice axes and crampons, it would have been extremely difficult to pull my wet and frozen body up out of those overhanging ice walls. If the shock of the ice water didn’t kill me, it seems unlikely that I would have had the presence of mind to remain calm and work out a way to get myself out of there. I can imagine myself attempting to rescue my camera and tripod from the water before even thinking about saving myself. I have a strange confidence in my ability to remain calm in emergency situations. Years of high risk rock climbing have probably created that innate confidence, but I suspect it might have been seriously shaken once dropped over my head into seething ice water. I say that here, but the truth is, at some level I still believe I would have more or less calmly gone about the business of trying to get myself out of the water.
None of this thinking actually happens while I’m out there taking pictures. For the most part, I think “Huh, look at that! That water actually knocked a block of ice out of there and made a hole. Good thing I was standing over here.” That’s really about it. Mild surprise. I’m a little chastened, but not really scared. I never even think about what it would mean to fall in that water. I give the edges of the holes a little wider berth, but I go about my business, moving about the ice and looking for different compositions along the edges of these little ice fjords.
The entire shoreline is a series of these water carved inlets and each one is a different shape and gives me a different look in the viewfinder, so I move along the ice for a while, shooting different inlets. The light is coming up slowly, so now the exposure are a few seconds and moving toward a second or two. In several places, I shoot multiple exposures, trying to catch particularly large waves as they come in and splash spray into the air. The timing is a little challenging as I’m using a two second timer to help eliminate any shaking of the camera from my pressing the shutter button. I make several efforts at a few different places.
At one point, I’m moving between one inlet and another and I’m clambering over the uneven ice. I’m standing on what appear to be larger blocks of ice and I need to step down onto a lower surface, which is that same frozen slurpee looking stuff. It’s a couple of feet down so I have to take a big step down on one foot. It has not even occurred to me that this surface might not be stable. I’m well back from the outer edge of the ice and everything appears to be locked solidly in place. I take the step down. I land pretty hard on that one foot. It immediately punches through the frozen slurpee and into the water below. I feel my boot fill up with water instantly.

This is the hole my foot made in the ice. You can see the surface is not that thick.
I’ve fallen down on the ice, of course, my tripod and camera sprawling across the ice. I pull my foot up out of the hole I’ve made as quickly as possible and get myself up, collecting camera and tripod and looking for damage. My pant leg is wet well above the ankle. My boot is filled with ice water. At the moment, it does not really occur to me that I might easily have punched through the ice with my entire body as I crashed to the ice from up on that higher block. I look at the hole. It’s pretty neatly shaped exactly the size of my foot. The surface I’m standing on is apparently about six inches thick. It is a conglomerate of frozen snow and little chunks of ice. It’s not as uniform as a slurpee, but not too terribly different in consistency. Even as I stand and look into the hole, it does not occur to me that it really didn’t take too much force for me to punch through. All I did was step down off this higher block. It was a hard step down, but not that hard. I could easily drop through the ice anywhere just for standing there. I can’t see the bottom in the hole I’ve made. I don’t think it’s that deep. I’m probably thirty feet offshore, but I have the sense that the ice goes all the way to the bottom. Obviously it doesn’t. Nonetheless, I calmly walk off to examine the next fjord.
I shoot for another twenty minutes or so, moving around the ends of the fjords, composing photographs. I’m liking what I’m seeing. The sun has apparently now come up over the horizon, because there is a brilliant fuschia color to the clouds to the south down the beach. I try a couple of shots of this, but there’s really nothing to hold the composition together and I doubt that the shots will be of much interest. I’m monitoring my right foot to see if it’s freezing. The boot is still filled with water, but I’m wearing pretty good wool socks and I note that wool really does seem to insulate fairly well when wet. Really wet.
I take a last couple of exposures. The light is starting to get less interesting as the sun comes up and I’ve got what I wanted from here. My pant leg is starting to freeze into a big donut around my ankle, so I head for shore. I walk over the same kind of frozen slurpee concoction on my way back to shore without a second thought. I do stop to take a couple of pictures of the hole I made in the ice, just for kicks.
I make my way back to the beach proper. As I head in, I look up at the dark windows of some condos on the beach. It occurs to me that if anyone had been watching me from their bedroom window, they would have seen me step off of that block of ice and disappear, as if into the water. Anyone with any sense at all would have called 911 immediately.

One more shot from out at the edge of the ice. It has a truly eerie quality to it.
I cross the sand and wade back through the snow drifts to get to the car. My pants look pretty funny as they move rigidly up and down my leg with each footstep in the deep snow. I’m almost to the car now and I know that I’m in no danger of freezing my foot. It’s cold, but not numb. I’d probably be good for another half hour if I had to stay out.
Back at the car, I load the camera and tripod and backpack into the back of the truck and climb into the driver’s seat. I start the car, and turn up the heater. I’m flushed with the pleasure of having been outside and seen and done something that most people wouldn’t bother to do. I’m so glad that I got up this morning and resisted that moment of wavering in my commitment. This has really been worthwhile.
Lying in bed last night, after returning home, I think back over my little morning adventure. I’ve looked at the pictures a couple of times during the evening. It’s hard to tell if they’re really good enough. They look pretty cool, but I think they would have been better if I could have gotten a little closer to the edge of the water and filled the frame with more water and less ice in the foreground. Obviously, that would have been unwise at best, but I’m not sure the pictures are as good as I’d like. I’ll find out as I do my editing. There ought to be at least one decent shot in the bunch. It’s a scene I’ve never seen shot before. It’s alien and unfamiliar and pretty dramatic. It has that sense of mystery and vastness that I love in my photographs.
But lying in bed, a little of the fear comes up that should have occurred to me while I was out on the ice. I can feel the adrenaline pumping through my body. I’m hyper-ventilating a little bit. It’s subtle, but I can feel the rush of fear. The surging of the water, the eerie galumphing sound the waves made as they sloshed against the underside of the hollow ice, come back to me. I realize that my subconscious heard that sound and was alarmed. My conscious mind just heard the sound and noticed it. My subconscious knew it was a sign of danger. I’m a little afraid I’ll have nightmares tonight. Surging, greenish water, smooth ice walls well over my head.
I’m turning over scenarios in my mind. What if I couldn’t climb up the walls? Would I swim out of the fjord and along the face of the ice, looking for another way out. I think about whether I could make it to the pier and whether there might be a way out there. No way. It’s a quarter mile away and that would be hard enough in warm water. I probably wouldn’t make it out of the fjord I fell into. I would only have a couple of minutes before my muscles were too stiff and weak to do anything. My mind would get fuzzy and I would lose the ability to think rationally about what to do. I’d wind up a popsicle in a matter of minutes. I’d be frozen into the ice.
They would probably find me before I wound up spending the winter frozen out there. My Dad would get up in an hour or two and eventually wonder where I was. I told him I might go take pictures. My car is parked in the lot and would be easy to find. It’s bright yellow, after all. But I’d be long gone, that’s for sure.
I try to relax. I won’t be able to sleep if I keep turning these kinds of thoughts over in my head. I don’t want to have nightmares. It’s time to take a few deep breaths and turn off these thoughts.